Ignored
by Mark W. Tiedemann
This is somewhat confessional. Over the last couple
of decades of trying to put together a writing career, time and again a
rather annoying set of responses on my part have surfaced, making
me rather self-conscious. I dislike the kind of unctuous and pleading "Dig
Me-ism" displayed by a certain kind of social climber. The person who name-drops,
tries to force their way into every "important" party, and feels slighted
with each instance of being overlooked and does everything possible to
draw attention to the fact that "Hey, I’m someone, too!"
Often, such people aren’t "someone", if you take
my meaning, and their attempts at rectifying the less-than-wowed reaction--or
nonreactions, really--of those from whom they believe they deserve attention
are pitiable.
Yet I tend to do that.
It’s a catch-22, of course. The one thing that is
required to be even a little successful in this business is a degree of
public recognition. If no one knows you’re publishing, or that your last
story or novel are out, and ought to be paid attention to, then you don’t
make any sales and your career stands a good chance of ending prematurely
(in your opinion, at any rate). Being ignored is a slow death for an artist.
So you find yourself trying to do things to make sure you aren’t ignored.
Doing them in the wrong way, with the wrong emphasis
on the problem, can backfire, and garner you even LESS attention.
I have a curiously paradoxical reaction to all this.
I’m rather uncomfortable when the spotlight gets put on me. At our local
major convention last year I was presented with an award. I did not expect
it, never thought the con committee would ever think highly enough of me
to give me an award, and they managed to catch me flatfooted at the banquet.
I was completed flummoxed. Normally, I can manage some badinage in public,
good or bad, but I was so stunned and so self-conscious at the event that
I was literally speechless. I muttered out a "Thank You!"--sincerely felt
and genuinely meant--and staggered back to my seat, stunned, and wishing
to become invisible. Minutes before that, there had been a dinner theater,
in which I had a speaking part, and participated with enthusiasm, even
managing to provoke laughs. But that was a character. Now it was just Me,
and I cringed.
Yet I want that kind of attention and I am one of
those people who chafe when I don’t get it.
I cannot stand being ignored.
To be fair, it is my work that I can’t tolerate
being ignored. For several years, a certain reviewer of short fiction consistently
and rigorously failed to notice my stories. I thought this was an aberration
for a while--after all, he didn’t review every story in a given magazine
anyway--until, two reviews in a row, he mentioned every story in both magazines
EXCEPT MINE. He didn’t even trash them. Just pretended they weren’t there.
I have no idea what his problem was. But it upset
me tremendously.
I have yet to have a novel reviewed in Locus. I
don’t know what the deal is, but my tenth book came out in July of ‘05
and I’ve never been reviewed in the main periodical of my chosen field.
Now, I have not been ignored altogether. COMPASS
REACH was shortlisted for the Philip K. Dick Award in 2002, a signal honor.
I’ve been asked this year to be a judge for that same award. COMPASS REACH
also, barely, managed to make the preliminary Nebula Ballot that year as
well. I’ve been reviewed two or three times in SciFiction, Ellen Datlow’s
recently defunct web magazine.
But there hasn’t been a lot. People don’t mention
my novels to any significant degree in the Usenet groups; my own local
newspaper has never reviewed me; I pass, it seems, unremarked through much
of fandom and the reading public.
Nevertheless, I am not totally ignored. Yet often
I feel like the kid who is the last chosen for the team during recess,
because no one wants him.
I tracked this down, finally. It is a neurosis and
I can do without one.
In high school, I became an avid photographer. Got
pretty good at it, I think. I’ve made a living at it, one way or another,
since then, so I must do it pretty well.
There was an annual competition then, the KINSA--Kodak
Independent Newspaper Snapshot Award--which had a division for high school
photography. There were three of us from my school who entered. One of
the others also continued to make a living in photography and still does.
The third was his girlfriend at the time.
I put together a broad range of 11 X 14 prints to
submit. In fact, I submitted the maximum number allowed. The other guy
submitted three prints, his girlfriend one or two. Submission was through
an art teacher at another school.
Now, what followed was to some degree my fault,
but not enough so to justify what transpired. I printed my entrees on a
particular kind of paper which had the unfortunate attribute of "scuffing"
easily. It was labeled "Velvet Surface" and the scuffing was very much
like what you would get if you ran your fingernail over a piece of black
velvet. Not much, but enough to look...well, not good.
So to protect against any accidental scuffing, I
put a piece of tissue paper over each print. (I used this paper because
it also had a very rich tonal quality and the prints really stood out.)
The tissue paper was scotch taped on four sides.
Tissue paper.
We awaited the results. There were three grand prizes
and then a large number of what they called "Key Awards", which were basically
certificates, and display in the traveling Kodak KINSA show that would
tour the country.
Both my classmates got keys. We waited. Nothing.
Then I got word to come pick up my entrees. When
I did, they were all there.
And not one bit of tissue paper had been removed.
The judges had not even looked at them.
As this fact sank in over the next several days,
I also sank into such a pit of disappointed and self-loathing pity that
I couldn’t stand myself. I hadn’t even been given a chance, either because
some judge didn’t want to be bothered peeling off the tissue or they thought
the image through the tissue was the actual point--I tried to imagine a
dozen scenarios. The bottom line was, I didn’t get a Key. I thought at
the time my work was better, but now I can at least say that it was just
as good, than the other two entrees, and when I went to the show a month
later I couldn’t help but think that I had been royally and inexcusably
screwed out of my place.
To be rejected because the work was bad would be
one thing. It would have hurt, sure. But to not even be considered...
Sure, I should have used a more common paper that
wouldn’t have required "protection". I should perhaps have sent fewer prints.
There are many reasons I can come up with in retrospect that would explain
why my entire entree was sent back unexamined.
Nevertheless, when you’re 17, and that kind of thing
happens, it cuts deep.
Ever since then I’ve had a pathological aversion
to being ignored.
It pops up at the most annoying times, but often--more
often than not--I’m alone, at home, or somewhere in private. Hopefully
I haven’t yet made an ass of myself, like one of those people I described
at the beginning of this essay. I need to deal with this, put it to rest,
and fix it before I do. It’s bad enough how unspectacular things are just
now, it wouldn’t help to make of myself someone to be avoided.
Because there’s a certain kind of person I would
like to be. I had my sites set on it long ago and tried to stick to the
path of becoming that person. Maybe everybody does this, maybe not. I wonder
how many people just go with whatever flow happens to be flowing and accept
what turns out to be their lot, whatever it may be. I don’t know. I’ve
tried to be self-directed. The hard part is less figuring out what you
want to be than actually integrating it with yourself in a natural and
honest way. I think a lot of people who one might tag as "fake" or "phony"
have managed to construct an attribute or suite of attributes, and instead
of them coming naturally from who they are, they wear those qualities like
clothes, and they seem inauthentic. (As opposed to those who "put on an
act" in order to get something they want--that’s duplicity and fundamentally
dishonest, something I’ve also done, mainly because I didn’t know how else
to do it, but sometimes--I said this was confessional--because there was
something I wanted and I knew that being "myself" would pretty much guarantee
not getting it. This goes to the heart of what we mean when we talk about
trade-offs and the worth of things, that maybe if getting that something
you really want might not be worth the price of self-betrayal. But that’s
a mature onsideration and there was a time when none of us were mature.
Those of you who never found yourselves in a position to trade your Self
for an object of desire may not get the fact that you reached maturity
in this regard more or less untested. I don’t know. To paraphrase T.E.
Lawrence, you can be what you want, but you can’t always choose what you
want. Values come with experience, something the fundies don’t seem to
understand. But that’s another Muse...)
Anyway, life does throw all kinds of stuff in your
way that make it hard to be what you want. I want to write full time and
work from home. Not such a big thing, you might say, but so far I’ve been
unable to make the kind of money from my words that would allow me to do
that. So until I can do that I find myself working a job I don’t want,
spending hours of my day doing things I don’t want to do, and delaying
the day I can institute some of the attributes--perhaps they’re just "furniture"--I
would like to.
Some of what holds me back has to do with reactions
I developed decades ago and find I must dig down to find and excise, because
they do me no go, and may actually harm me.
What harm?
Well, right off the bat, it blunts my appreciation
of what I do have.
I have love in my life. I have friends. I have the
ability to actually do the things that I think are important to me, just
not quite at the level I want to do them. Most of my genuine complaints
are problems of degree. I write and I manage to publish. Not as much or
as successfully as I like, but there are so damn few who really get to
do this AT ALL, that I should feel like an ingrate bitching about it. I
play music, occasionally well enough to do so in front of people. I’d like
very much to have two hours a day to practice so I could play as well as
I think I can. But I get to play!
I can read books--I own books--there are so many
people who can’t (or don’t) but in fact will never get the chance to.
Time and tenacity will take care of my career problems.
I can get past all this.
And maybe I’ll feel comfortable in my own skin.
But not till I get rid of some of these old wounds
that do me no good to carry around.
Just wanted to share a little of this with you.
Thanks for listening.