I’m going to go out on a limb here and make some statements which may not be dependable. You are warned. I’m speculating.
But I want some optimism, so…
With the dismissal of Bannon, it is obvious—or should be—that there is no center to this administration. The Donald had no plans, no principles to defend, no competencies to bring to bear. From the beginning he was indulging in pure deal-making showmanship, and now that he has to deliver we see that the fine cloak of carnival hucksterism is draped over nothing. He is entirely about Making A Deal. He thought that’s all he had to do, come into Washington and start wheeling and dealing as if the business of the nation was no more than a complex set of real estate negotiations that required someone who could sit down and negotiate a Deal. In his conception of that, though, you base your negotiating principles on bluff and managing to get one over on the other guy. As long as you come out ahead—however you conceive of that—you’re successful. The one thing that is de rigeur, though, is that nothing is to be allowed to get in the way of the Deal.
Not even your own biases.
So we see exactly how that works in practice with the dismal display over Charlottesville. Don’t take a side, you might have to make a Deal with those guys later. If possible, make all positions roughly equal so that you somehow hold the upper hand.
This doesn’t work so well with people on the street and it works even worse with countries. You try to make China look bad so you can deal on trade imbalances, but the rhetoric you choose makes it difficult to then ask for help when North Korea acts up. And threatening North Korea as part of a bluff to get them to open up to deal doesn’t work with a leadership that thinks it has already won.
On a practical, domestic level, you make promises that require a lot of other people to sign on for without any kind of guidance on where to go with these promises, because, as a “master” dealmaker you know you can bait-and-switch. You can get them into that turkey you’ve been wanting to unload if you can just get them to the table and pliant. They either walk away with nothing or take your offer, and no one wants to walk away with nothing. They do business with you now so they can do a better deal later.
But an even deeper problem lies with the people who helped him into office. We know them now, we can see what they are, and recognize the disregard and empty polemic and the class bias and the sheer disrespect they carry with them in lieu of an actual conscience. They think everyone is just like them and when it turns out that they’re wrong they have nothing to fall back on.
Now, I suspect that had this bunch come into power in 2008 we would be in even worse trouble. The country was on the ropes then, people were terrified, insecure, the economy was in a tailspin, and everyone was out to blame someone. We might have had a deeply serious problem had this bunch gotten into power then. They would be just as inept but we would have less confidence in our ability to challenge the obscenities. The comparisons to Germany in 1932 are apt but they go only so far. These folks are eight years and an economic recovery too late.
Oh, they can still do damage—they are doing damage. But they’re doing more damage to themselves.
Bannon was dismissed because, somehow, he threatened the Deal. Whatever the Deal might be. The Deal is amorphous, unformed. You throw things out there until something coalesces, then you recognize what it’s going to be, and you start arranging the furniture to make it happen. But Bannon wasn’t interested in that. He wanted to assert a position, he had a clear agenda. Can’t have that and keep the Deal fluid. He was an unreliable negotiator. His strategy, whatever it was, would have required his boss to give up options. Can’t do that, the Deal isn’t shaped yet. When he said the presidency he and the others fought for is over, that’s what he meant. The goals he thought they were all going after are being traded for advantage, used as negotiating chips in some Deal.
It all has no center. No substance. It’s collapsing. The scramble to make appearances count for reality is failing.
So my bit of optimism. We’re going through a long-overdue purge. It will be better. All we have to do is vomit out the residue of old beliefs that, in most instances, only served to distract us from our darker selves.
It’s going to be all right.